For a printable version of this document, click the link below.

CPP Class Action (PDF)

You will need Acrobat Reader in order to open, view and print the above file. To get the free Acrobat Reader, click the link below.





Smith & Hughes - Out/Law Online


CPP Class ActionWhat's New

BACKGROUNDER

Same Sex Benefits Class Action Lawsuit

What is a class action?
A law suit started by one or more persons seeking relief on behalf of a defined class of persons.

Why Start a class action?
There may be a number of people who are impacted in a similar way by the action of another person or institution.
There are efficiencies in grouping the claims under one lawsuit as opposed to having each person start their own lawsuit.
The people in the class can have their claims adjudicated together.
There is no possibility of inconsistent judgments for the members of the class.
There may be a greater possibility of a settlement for the entire class due to a "level playing field".
The Act provides a notification process that ensures that everyone who has rights will receive notice of their entitlement.

What are the steps in a class action?
The first step is to issued the Statement of Claim with the Court.
When the Statement of Claim has been issued, the person commencing the action must obtain a court order certifying the proceeding as a class proceeding and appointing the person as the class representative.
Once the class proceeding has been certified, the members of the class are given notice of the class proceeding.
After these steps, the action is litigated in the usual course, with examinations for discovery, and so on, proceeding to a trial.

What is this class action about?
The federal government has excluded the class members from receiving a survivor’s pension under the Canada Pension Plan because of their sexual orientation.
The lawsuit claims pensions and pension arrears that were not paid because of discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation is prohibited under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Who are the class members?
These class members were in same sex relationships that have been generally recognized under federal law under Bill C-23 that was passed following M v H.
All of them had common law partners who died before January 1, 1998 and who contributed to the CPP throughout their working lives.
When their common law partners died, they applied for a CPP survivor’s pension.
They were denied a CPP survivor’s pension because of their sexual orientation.

How many people are in the class?
Approximately 5,000 people could be in the national class

  • Over 400 people have already contacted the legal team
  • there have been few inquiries from estates of decease class members
  • in some instances both partners have died
  • a variable percentage of individuals entitled to a benefit from a class action decision actually claim it
  • there is confusion between CPP survivor and death benefits
  • the Government estimates the class size at 1,500.

What is a CPP survivor’s pension?
Under the Canada Pension Plan, a contributor to the plan receives a pension income upon retirement.
The contributor’s spouse or common law partner is also entitled to receive a survivor’s pension when the contributor dies, however, this does not apply to the class members.

Didn’t the federal government extend benefits to same sex couples?
In July 2000, the federal government introduced legislation which extended certain rights and obligations to same sex couples.
Under this legislation, same sex couples are defined under the heading of "common law partner".
The legislation changed certain aspects of the CPP so that a person in a same sex relationship is entitled to receive a CPP survivor’s pension, but only if their partner died on or after January 1, 1998.
This limitation does not apply to heterosexuals, whether married or cohabiting in common law relationships.

Is there a class action in Quebec?
Quebec has its own plan which may be the subject of litigation there.




Send website-related questions or comments to webadmin@smith-hughes.com.
Copyright © 1997-2005 Smith & Hughes

 
HOME · ABOUT US · WHAT'S NEW · CPP CLASS ACTION · SAME SEX MARRIAGE
PUBLICATIONS · OUT/LAW IMMIGRATION · HOT LINKS